After a crash or a fall, one of the first things an insurance company may suggest is that the accident was partly your fault. Maybe you were driving a few miles over the speed limit, or glanced at your phone just before you slipped. Many injured people assume that any share of blame ends their claim. In Pennsylvania, that is usually not the case.
How Comparative Negligence Works in Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania follows a rule called modified comparative negligence. Under this rule, an injured person can still recover compensation even if they were partly responsible for the accident, as long as their share of the fault is not greater than the share of the party or parties they are seeking compensation from.
In practical terms, this means:
- If you were 50 percent or less at fault, you can still recover, but your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault.
- If you were 51 percent or more at fault, you generally cannot recover compensation from the other parties.
For example, suppose a jury decides your damages total $100,000 and finds you 20 percent responsible for the accident. Your recovery would be reduced by 20 percent, to $80,000. If the jury instead found you 60 percent responsible, you would generally recover nothing.
When More Than One Party Is at Fault
Many accidents involve more than one responsible party. A multi-vehicle crash might involve several drivers, and a fall on commercial property might involve both a property owner and a maintenance company. In these cases, your share of the fault is generally compared against the combined fault of everyone you are pursuing. That means you may still be able to recover even if your share of the blame is larger than any single defendant’s, as long as it is not larger than all of theirs together.
How Insurance Companies Use Fault Against Injured People
Because every percentage point of fault reduces what an insurer may have to pay, arguing that you share the blame is one of the most common ways insurance companies try to lower the value of a claim. Common arguments include:
- In car accidents: that you were speeding, distracted, following too closely, or could have avoided the crash.
- In slip and fall cases: that you were not watching where you were walking, wore unsafe footwear, or ignored a warning sign.
- In pedestrian accidents: that you crossed outside a crosswalk or against a signal.
Some of these arguments have merit, and many do not. The percentage an insurance adjuster assigns to you is not the final word. Fault is ultimately a question of evidence, and if a case goes to trial, it is decided by a judge or jury.
What About Seat Belts?
Wearing a seat belt is required in many situations under Pennsylvania law, and it is always the safest choice. But if you were injured in a crash while not wearing a seat belt, Pennsylvania law generally does not allow that fact to be used as evidence against you in a civil lawsuit. An insurer may still raise it during negotiations, but it generally cannot be used to reduce your compensation in court.
Protecting Yourself Against Unfair Blame
Because fault can significantly affect the value of a claim, the steps you take early on matter. Photographs of the scene, witness contact information, surveillance or dashcam video, and medical records can all help establish what really happened. It is also wise to be careful about what you say to an insurance company before you understand your rights, since casual statements like “I didn’t see them” can later be used to shift blame onto you.
Pennsylvania also has strict time limits for filing personal injury claims, and evidence such as video footage can disappear quickly. The sooner your claim is investigated, the better positioned you are to respond to fault arguments.
How Wood Legal Can Help
If an insurance company is blaming you for an accident that injured you, Wood Legal can review what happened and help you understand where you stand. We represent injured people only, never insurance companies, and personal injury cases are handled on a contingency basis, with no upfront cost. Contact us today for a free case review.